The Impact of Conflicts of Interest on the Developments of the Elections Law of the Islamic Consultative Assembly: A Case Study of the Conditions for Candidates

Mazinani, Alireza; Bahadori  Jahrami, Mohammad; Shabani Jahrami, Mohammad

doi:10.22034/qjplk.2024.1931.1744

The Impact of Conflicts of Interest on the Developments of the Elections Law of the Islamic Consultative Assembly: A Case Study of the Conditions for Candidates

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

¹ MSc. Student in Public Law. Faculty of Law. Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.

² Assistant Professor. Departement of Public Law. Faculty of Law. Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.

³ Ph. D. Student in Public Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh tabatabai university, Tehran, Iran.

10.22034/qjplk.2024.1931.1744

Abstract

The Elections Law of the Islamic Consultative Assembly is unparalleled in terms of the number of changes made to it throughout the history of legislation in Iran. A common point among many of these changes is the expansion of the circle of those disqualified from candidacy in elections. Given that most representatives in each legislative term run for election in the next term, there arises a suspicion regarding the impact of conflicts of interest on these changes. This research, conducted through a descriptive-analytical method with a legal perspective, seeks to answer the question of what role conflicts of interest have played in the legislative changes affecting the conditions for candidates in the elections of the Islamic Consultative Assembly. The findings indicate that many of the positive and negative conditions for candidates added to the Elections Law over the past four decades are stringent and are either rare or unique compared to electoral laws in other countries. In practice, it seems that some of these conditions have not significantly contributed to the selection of qualified candidates; instead, they have unjustifiably disqualified many capable individuals from running for election. Considering this evidence and indications, it can be asserted that conflicts of interest may indeed be one of the main factors influencing changes in the Elections Law of the Islamic Consultative Assembly. Many representatives over various terms have sought to eliminate their competitors from the electoral scene by establishing unreasonable conditions for candidates.

Keywords

Main Subjects

other

References

References

Books

Ajorlo, A. (2015), Fundamental Rights of Islamic Countries, Tehran: Guardian Council Research Institute Publications.

Ahmadi, A. (2008), Elections in Iran, Tehran: Mizan Publishing.

Amiri, H. (2015), Pathology of the Legislative System in the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Mizan Publishing.

Jafari Langroudi, M. (1999), expanded on legal terminology, Tehran: Ganj Danesh Library, second volume, first edition.

Khosravi, H. (2018). Laws of Democratic Elections, Tehran: Majd Publishing House, third edition.

Rose, R. (2011), International Encyclopedia of Elections, translated by Mohammad Taghi Delfrooz, Tehran: Mizan Publishing.

Zarei, M. (2004), Comparative Study of Legislative Assemblies, Tehran: Islamic Parliament Research Center Publications.

Zantaki, H. (2022), Law Writing: The Art and Technology of Regulatory Rules, translated by Hasan Vakilian, Tehran: Samt Publishing House.

Abbasi Lahiji, b. (2021), Comparative Constitutional Law, Tehran: dadgostar Publications, 4th edition.

Kaabi, A. (2018), Analyzing the Basics of the System of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Guardian Council Research Institute Publications, Volume 1.

Qazi Shariatpanahi, A. (2021). Fundamental rights and political institutions, Tehran: Mizan publishing house, 16th edition.

Mansourian, M. (2016), the legal system governing elections; Electoral systems, Tehran: Guardian Council Research Institute Publications, first volume, third edition.

Articles, theses and research reports

Ismaili, M. and Mansourian, M. (2011), an introduction to the role of the Islamic Parliament in the implementation of the general policies of the system, Public Law Review Quarterly, 1 (2), 1-22.

Agha Abdullahi, R. (2014), Comparative Parliamentary Studies 5; The conditions for candidacy in the parliamentary elections of some countries, a research report of the Research Center of the Islamic Parliament, Office of Political Studies.

Ansari, b. (2022), Managing Conflicts of Interest in the Public Sector, Public Law Studies Quarterly, 52 (1), 321-297.

Taghizadeh, J. (2006) {A}, general conditions of electability in political elections, law and political science research paper, (2 and 3), 55-85.

Taghizadeh, J. (2008) {B}, special conditions of electability in political elections, Constitutional Law Journal, 4 (7), 1-21.

Taghizadeh, J. (2008), Ineligibility in the election law of the Islamic Parliament and local Islamic councils with a look at French law, Comparative Law Research, 13 (4), 1127-1148.

Habibnejad, SA. (2011), the conditions of being elected in the Islamic Parliament elections in Iran's constitutional law system with a comparative view, Political Science Journal, 4 (55), 130-99.

Rezaizadeh, M. and Davari, M. (2015), Basics and principles of recognition of the competence of the representative of the Islamic Parliament, Knowledge of Public Law Quarterly, 5 (14), 117-142.

Zinalu, M. and Ali Ahmadi, A. and Nariman, S. (2018), Investigating the causes of conflicts of interest in the representatives of the Islamic Parliament, Public Policy Quarterly, 5 (2), 117-99.

Samadi, S. (1995), comparative study of parliamentary election laws of 110 countries in the world, {Master's Thesis}, Tehran: Tarbiat Madras University.

Tahan Nazif, H. and Qalichpour, S. (2021), pathology of determining the conditions of candidates for Islamic Parliament representation in the light of the constitution and general election policies, Danesh Public Law Quarterly, 10 (31), 19-42.

Abbasi, b. and Jafari, M. (2011), a comparative study of the conditions of electors and electors in the electoral system of Iranian and Malaysian parliaments, Journal of Comparative Law, 2 (2), 115-132.

Documents and rules

The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran approved in 1979.

The general election policies announced on 2015 by the Supreme Leader.

The Law on Elections of the National Parliament of the Islamic Republic of Iran approved on 1979 by the Revolutionary Council of the Islamic Republic of Iran and subsequent amendments.

Islamic Parliament Elections Law, approved on 1983, Islamic Parliament and subsequent amendments.

Islamic Parliament Elections Law approved on 1999 of the Islamic Parliament and subsequent amendments.

Internet sites

www.khamenei.ir

www.nazarat.shora-rc.ir