The Possibility And Mechanisms of Recognizing The Ability to Declare Collection in The Islamic Council Based on The General Policies of The Legislative Regime

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PHD student, faclty of law, Department of Public Law, shahid beheshty university, Tehran, Iran

2 Assistant professor, faclty of law, Department of Public Law, Tarbiat Modares university, Tehran, Iran

3 MA. in (Public law), faclty of law, Department of Public Law, Imam Sadeq university, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Increasing bills without expert support and decreasing the quality of laws and non-implementation of laws are among the problems of Iran's legislative system. One of the solutions to solve this issue is to carry out expert activities before announcing the receipt and include a guarantee of non-announcement of receipt for non-expert bills. Therefore, the question arises whether in the legal system of the Islamic Republic of Iran it is possible to require components to announce the receipt of legislative drafts? If the answer is positive, what is the mechanism for determining the feasibility of the bill in the parliament? This research has tried to answer this question by descriptive-analytical method and using library resources. As a result, although in the existing procedure, announcing the receipt of bills is not optional; However in Iran's legal system, it is possible to determine the components to recognize the declaration of collection in the Islamic parliament within the framework of the Iran's constitution. These components can be determined and gradually implemented using the capacity of the general policies of the legislative system. Finally, in order to guarantee the rights of representation, their verification must be formal. In addition to this strategy, in case of lack of information or technical complexities of the issue, the parliament can advance its goals by using empowering laws. The declaration of receipt of such drafts does not require verification of the mentioned components.

Keywords

References

A) Books, articles and theses:
Abdul Ahad, A. (2018). Pathology of the Legislative System of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Expert Report of the Islamic Council Research Center. (In Persian)
Abrishmi Rad, M., Kodkhodaei, A. (2015). "The Procedure of the Guardian Council Regarding the Principles and Criteria Ruling on Legislative Initiative". Quarterly Journal of Public Law Knowledge, 13. 1-22.
Amini Baghbadrani, Masoud (2011). An Applied Study of the Delegation of Legislative Discretion in the Legal Systems of the Islamic Republic of Iran and France.Iran: Shiraz University. (In Persian)
Ansari, Baqir (2018). Principles and Techniques of Legislation; Preparation of draft Plans and Bills, Revision and Compilation of Laws. Tehran: Justice Publishing House. (In Persian)
Dehghan Benadaki, Ali. (2021). expert opinion on: "Amendment plan for articles of the law of internal regulations of the parliament" (the first part of the legislative process). Tehran: Research Center of the Islamic Council. serial number 17963. (In Persian)
Executive Branch Agencies Congress's Authority to Influence and Control
Executive Branch Agencies'. Congressional Research Service, Serial number: R45442.
Executive Branch Agencies’. Congressional Research Service, Serial number: R45442.
Executive Branch AgenciesCongress’s Authority to Influence and Control
Garvey, Todd; Stiff, sean M. (2023). ‘Congress’s Authority to Influence and Control.
Garvey, Todd; Stiff, Sean M. (2023). 'Congress's Authority to Influence and Control.
Habibzadeh, T. (2014). "Judicial review and American Supreme Court’s approaches to interpretation of the Constitution in the light of the political and social evolutions". Quarterly Journal of Public Law Knowledge. 10. 113-140.
Khalaf Rezaei, H. (2014). "Approaches to Constitutional Interpretation; with Regard to the Guardian Council’s Decisions", Knowledge Quarterly Journal of Public Law Knowledge, (7), 73-93. (In Persian)
Kuenji, Moyil. (2008). Improving the efficiency of legislative procedures of parliament, translated by Hassan Vakilian. Majlis Research Center. serial number 9426. (In Persian)
Lovelock, Lynn; Evens, John (2008). New South Wales Legislation Council Practice. Sydney: The Federation Press.
Lovelock, Lynn; Evens, John (2008). New South Wales Legislation Council Practice. Sydney: The Federation Press.
Muezzin, R. (2014). General Economic Law: A Comparative Study of Iran and France. Tehran: Majd Publications. (In Persian)
Sharif, M. (2005). "Gas Wins Legal Hierarchy Pervasive Cultural Revolution even Higher". Public Law Research Quarterly, 7 (16), 213-249.
Tabatabayi Mottamani, M. (2007). Fundamental Rights. Tehran: Mizan.
The Research Institute of the Guardian Council. (2021). Outline of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran, second volume. Tehran: Publications of the Research Institute of the Guardian Council. (In Persian)
Vaezi, A. (2019). legal hermeneutics. Qom: Bostan Kitab Institute. (In Persian)
Yavari, Asadullah et al. (2016). principles and criteria of judicial interpretation in public law. Tehran: Judiciary Publications. (In Persian)
Zantaki, H. (2022). Law writing art and technology of regulation rules. translated by Hassan Vakilian. Tehran: Samt and Majlis Islamic Shura Publications. (In Persian)
Zapatero Gomez, V. (2019). The Art of Legislation. Switzerland: Springer.
Zarshkan Abed, L. (2008). Evaluating the effects of the law, Tehran: Islamic Parliament Research Center. (In Persian)
 
B) Laws and documents
Interpretation theory No. 583/21/76 dated (31/5/1997) of the Guardian Council regarding the seventy-third principle. (In Persian)
Interpretive theory of the Guardian Council No. 9751 dated (19/10/1983) regarding the ninety-eighth principle. (In Persian)
Statement of the Guardian Council No. 5814/102/94 dated (13/12/2013) regarding "Compulsory insurance bill for damages caused to third parties due to accidents caused by vehicles". (In Persian)
The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran approved in (1979) with the amendment of (1989) . (In Persian)
The general policies of the administrative system of the notification of the Supreme Leader in (2019). (In Persian)
The general policies of the legislative system of the notification of the Supreme Leader in (2018). (In Persian)
The internal regulations of the Islamic Council approved in (1379) with subsequent amendments and additions. (In Persian)
The Law on the Duties and Powers of the Head of the Judiciary approved in( 1999). (In Persian)
Public Law Knowledge Quarterly
Volume 12, Issue 4 - Serial Number 42
December 2024
Pages 145-170

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 14 November 2022
  • Revise Date: 23 May 2023
  • Accept Date: 11 July 2023

Share

How to cite

Statistics